An entire month dedicated to pies? With all the different types of tasty pies available, the treats deserve an entire month rather than just a day, so February has been designated as Great American Pie Month.
Our REALTORS® suggest taking a culinary journey this month to indulge in Long Island’s best pies at the following destinations:
- Torte Jeff Pie Co. & Bakery – 218 E. Main St., Port Jefferson, NY 11777
If the delicious smell of the pies and other baked goodies at Torte Jeff Pie Co. & Bakery doesn’t lure you in, the taste definitely will! Pie choices at the bakery near Port Jefferson homes for sale include pecan chocolate chip, toasted coconut custard, and key lime. In most cases, you can buy a pie already cooked or assembled so you can bake it in your own oven—whether you try to pass it off as homemade is up to you! In addition to its selection of sweet pies, the bakery sells savory pies like beef bourguignon pot pies, which are the perfect cold-weather comfort food. - Buttercooky Bakery – 217 Jericho Turnpike, Floral Park, NY 11001
Buttercooky Bakery has operated for over 50 years, bringing sweets like pies to Floral Park residents. It has since grown to add two more locations to its flagship bakery near Floral Park homes for sale. Pies come in 4-, 8-, and 10-inch sizes in options including apple, cherry, and blueberry in a crumb, lattice, or old-fashioned style, as well as lemon meringue, pecan, and brownie flavors. And as the bakery’s slogan says, “Baked with butter makes it better.” - Catalina’s Bake Shop – 1155 E. Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743
Catalina’s Bake Shop, located just around the corner from Huntington homes for sale, aims to put love and passion in every bite of their delectable desserts. The shop’s owner and namesake has extensive experience, having graduated from culinary school and then worked as the head decorator at a luxury Long Island hotel for more than a decade. Try the bakery’s key lime, coconut, pecan, and other flavors of fresh-baked pies, including some seasonal options that allow the shop to utilize the freshest ingredients.
- Sugarberry – 312 Sunrise Hwy., Rockville Centre, NY 11570
For mouthwatering pies and other treats made using the highest quality ingredients and the European art of baking, head to Sugarberry, which you’ll find near Rockville Centre homes for sale. Goodies are continually baked fresh in the kitchen and placed in the bakery’s dessert gallery for you to choose which are the most appealing. Sit at one of the cozy space’s tables and enjoy your choice of apple, blueberry, coconut, chocolate mud, custard, cherry, or pumpkin pies. - Alpine Pastry Shoppe – 59 Route 111 (Hillside Village Center), Smithtown, NY 11787
For over 30 years, the Alpine Pastry Shoppe staff has baked fine Italian cakes, pastries, pies, and other goodies in Long Island. The family-owned-and-operated bakery is located near Smithtown homes for sale. Check out the tempting pies in the long glass display cases and try a banana cream made with the shop’s vanilla pudding with fresh bananas mixed in and topped with fresh whipped cream. Or go with a grain pie, a traditional Italian dessert filled with sweet ricotta and grains, or a favorite like an open blueberry, traditional blueberry, or blueberry crumb pie.
Contact us if you’re in the market for a home and would like to see Nassau County homes for sale and Suffolk County homes for sale. Our brokerage has helped homebuyers for 70 years, ascending to the top of the industry by providing exceptional real estate service.